Amendment I
Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people to peaceably assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
OK, so what were the founding fathers talking about here. While each of the amendments are occasionally co-opted by 1 group or another all the time to excuse their actions, I think that this one is most taken out of context and used to prove constitutionality of a law incorrectly or to incorrectly stop something from happening, i.e. prayers at high school or college graduations. I think that too often people think that the 1st amendment grants freedom FROM religion rather than freedom OF religion. If the founding fathers intended to build freedom from religion into the Constitution the amendment would read as follows:
Congress shall create laws disallowing the free exercise of any and all religion.
Now, I am a religious person, and as such, I am going to approach this subject with some personal bias. I do however feel that the founding fathers were at the very least deeply spiritual, if not devoted religious men. They did not intend for the country to be devoid of religion or for government to be devoid of religion. I believe that the founding fathers had a knowledge that their work was ordained of God and that they were creating an environment where religion and spirituality could prosper. What they did not want to occur was a theocracy to take root and for the government to institute a state mandated religion. They had left lands where religious intolerance abounded and where, in the case of England, if you were not Anglican, you were persecuted. They did, however, include God in all of their dealings, praying and invoking the name of Deity in all of their meetings and goings on. Why is this important? It is important, because too many people have invoked the First Amendment as an answer to the question of separation of church and state. This is a false premise. The first amendment has no such wording. All it states is that Congress can not institute a state run religion. That is it. Nowhere in this amendment or any other amendment to the Constitution does it say that Congress shall not allow religion to be invoked in government institutions. In fact to the contrary it says that Congress shall not prohibit "THE FREE EXERCISE THEREOF" Period, End Of Story. Is saying a prayer at a high school graduation not the free exercise of religion? Last I checked, if I am told that I can not pray, no matter where I am, that is limiting my free exercise of religion.
Also, by allowing a religious person to say a prayer at whatever function, is that the establishment of a religion? Of course not. If I go to a function and it is being presided over by a particular religious group, let's pick on the Catholics for this example, and they decide to open the function with a prayer, does that make me a Catholic? No, of course it doesn't. If that same group decided that they wanted to cater to other religions and had representatives from different religions perform invocations in their own custom and tradition, would I be offended? No. By creating laws banning prayer in schools, at school functions and banning religious artifacts in government buildings and sites, Congress is in fact violating the First Amendment. The Amendment does not say "Congress shall not prohibit the free exercise of religion, except in government offices" or "in institutions funded or subsidized by the government!"
I am sure that the topic of religion and the free exercise thereof will definitely come up again, so I'll leave it at that for now. Lets move on to Freedom of Speech and of The Press. I am not a constitutional lawyer (Thank Goodness), nor am I a Supreme Court Justice (many of you right now are saying "Thank Goodness"), but I think I have some common sense, and I wish more people would use it. I may not (and often don't) agree with everything that Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, and Glenn Beck say. And I may not (and rarely do) agree with anything Bill Maher, Bill Moyers, or Rachael Maddow say. Does that mean that they don't have the right to say them? Of course not. They have every right to say what they want. It is provided in this amendment. Do I have to agree with them? NO. Do I have to listen to them? NO. That is the beauty of the free market system. If enough people disagree with them, fewer people will listen, watch or read what they have to say. Advertisers will pull advertising, because they are unpopular and they will go by the wayside.
The first amendment does not say "Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, unless there is not a voice of opposition in a particular media, then Congress shall establish a fairness doctrine"
Lastly, we'll take a look at the right to peaceably assemble. Isn't this self explanatory? We as a people can get together to talk about or protest whatever we want. Let's just be adults about it. I am a staunch believer in many of the ideals put forth by the Tea Party movement. I think that what those people are doing is awesome. I am proud of those who marched for Civil Rights in the sixties. They were being fine upstanding citizens and doing their civic duty and minds, hearts, and laws changed because of it. I am also proud of anyone who PEACEABLY assembles to protest the immigration laws in Arizona. I may not agree with them, but they are doing their civic duty by assembling and letting their government know where they stand. Here is the caveat though. We MUST do it PEACEABLY! Once any type of violence occurs, all bets are off and the government has the right and responsibility to lock you up out of concern for the security of the people. Marching, Chanting and Protesting are all fine. Throw rocks at police officers though, and I want to see your butt in jail.
So there we go. That's my take on the First Amendment. I thank my Heavenly Father that I live in a country where what I just wrote will not land me in a dirty dingy cell. I am so thankful for the Fathers of our Nation who were inspired to write the Constitution and affirm the rights granted therein.
Also, by allowing a religious person to say a prayer at whatever function, is that the establishment of a religion? Of course not. If I go to a function and it is being presided over by a particular religious group, let's pick on the Catholics for this example, and they decide to open the function with a prayer, does that make me a Catholic? No, of course it doesn't. If that same group decided that they wanted to cater to other religions and had representatives from different religions perform invocations in their own custom and tradition, would I be offended? No. By creating laws banning prayer in schools, at school functions and banning religious artifacts in government buildings and sites, Congress is in fact violating the First Amendment. The Amendment does not say "Congress shall not prohibit the free exercise of religion, except in government offices" or "in institutions funded or subsidized by the government!"
I am sure that the topic of religion and the free exercise thereof will definitely come up again, so I'll leave it at that for now. Lets move on to Freedom of Speech and of The Press. I am not a constitutional lawyer (Thank Goodness), nor am I a Supreme Court Justice (many of you right now are saying "Thank Goodness"), but I think I have some common sense, and I wish more people would use it. I may not (and often don't) agree with everything that Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, and Glenn Beck say. And I may not (and rarely do) agree with anything Bill Maher, Bill Moyers, or Rachael Maddow say. Does that mean that they don't have the right to say them? Of course not. They have every right to say what they want. It is provided in this amendment. Do I have to agree with them? NO. Do I have to listen to them? NO. That is the beauty of the free market system. If enough people disagree with them, fewer people will listen, watch or read what they have to say. Advertisers will pull advertising, because they are unpopular and they will go by the wayside.
The first amendment does not say "Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, unless there is not a voice of opposition in a particular media, then Congress shall establish a fairness doctrine"
Lastly, we'll take a look at the right to peaceably assemble. Isn't this self explanatory? We as a people can get together to talk about or protest whatever we want. Let's just be adults about it. I am a staunch believer in many of the ideals put forth by the Tea Party movement. I think that what those people are doing is awesome. I am proud of those who marched for Civil Rights in the sixties. They were being fine upstanding citizens and doing their civic duty and minds, hearts, and laws changed because of it. I am also proud of anyone who PEACEABLY assembles to protest the immigration laws in Arizona. I may not agree with them, but they are doing their civic duty by assembling and letting their government know where they stand. Here is the caveat though. We MUST do it PEACEABLY! Once any type of violence occurs, all bets are off and the government has the right and responsibility to lock you up out of concern for the security of the people. Marching, Chanting and Protesting are all fine. Throw rocks at police officers though, and I want to see your butt in jail.
So there we go. That's my take on the First Amendment. I thank my Heavenly Father that I live in a country where what I just wrote will not land me in a dirty dingy cell. I am so thankful for the Fathers of our Nation who were inspired to write the Constitution and affirm the rights granted therein.
No comments:
Post a Comment